Thanksgiving Dinner and it's origin in Holland

In 1620 the Pilgrims sailed from ROTTERDAM to the New World.

Huh? Yes, read on.

The "birth" of the Pilgrims.
The Pilgrim story begins in Nottinghamshire, England. In about 1606, a group of English religious dissidents, whom we now know as "the Pilgrims," formed their own church independent of the national Church of England and its head, King James I. William Brewster, Richard Clifton, William Bradford and John Robinson and their families felt that their Christian faith required a greater degree of church reformation than was possible in the King's established Church. They therefore decided to gather themselves into a church of their own under a separate covenant. Such a move was considered treasonous at a time when church and state were united, and the Separatists, as they were called, were forced to flee the country lest they be imprisoned or even executed for their beliefs. Therefore, the group emigrated by 1609 to the tolerant haven of the Netherlands.

After a brief stay in Amsterdam, where they were dismayed by the discord within other immigrant English congregations, the Pilgrims were granted permission to settle in the cloth manufacturing city of Leiden. They lived there under the religious leadership of Pastor John Robinson for twelve years and gathered openly as a church. William Bradford became a member of The Leyden Wool Guild and William Brewster started his Pilgrim Press. The printing press was a relative new invention and Brewster printed his stirring pamphlets and books against King James, which were smuggled into England. Possession of these pamphlets and books in England meant long prison sentences or worse. The Pilgrim Press became the cause for a political incident between Holland and England, but the Dutch did not interfere with Brewster.

Although they were made welcome in Leiden and found no barriers to the practice of their faith, the Pilgrims still could not find peace and security. Their poverty, as foreigners at the bottom of the economic ladder, promised hardship in old age. Their living conditions made it difficult for the congregation to recruit additional English immigrants. They feared the loss of their English traditions as their children were growing up Dutch and there was a threat of renewed war between the Dutch and the Spanish. The twelve-year truce between Holland and Spain was to end in 1621, threatening a possible resumption of hostilities.

In 1618, the little congregation made the momentous decision to emigrate yet again. But where could they go? England, their old home, was still closed to them. They discussed settling in South America, but decided that the hot climate would "not well agree with our English bodies". There was also the menace of the neighboring Spanish. On the other hand, the Pilgrims were dubious about joining the English colony of Virginia for fear of suffering religious persecution once again. A later offer to settle under the auspices of the Dutch Government in New Amsterdam (now New York) was also rejected. In the end they decided to trust their countrymen in Virginia - but at the farthest remove possible. Their goal would be the northernmost boundary of the Virginia Company grant, at the mouth of the Hudson River (a captain for "The Dutch West Indies Company" named Hudson had discovered the river).

In 1620 The Pilgrims sailed from ROTTERDAM to the New World.
It was not possible to just go to the New World and settle. A patent or license to colonize was necessary and it took a sizable investment as well. In 1618, the Pilgrims began negotiations with the Virginia Company of London, with hopes of getting some assurance from the King that they would be left alone to practice their religion in America. Although the King would not formally promise this, the Pilgrims decided to accept what they viewed as his implicit assent and go ahead with their plans.

The Leiden congregation decided which of the group would go on the first voyage and which would wait until the plantation had been established. John Robinson, their leader stayed behind with his main congregation. They bought a small vessel called the Speedwell. The first emigrants left the port of Delftshaven (Rotterdam), amid tears, prayers and farewells on July 22, 1620.

The Pilgrim group sailed to Southampton, a city on the English south coast, where they were joined by additional immigrants, randomly recruited by the London Investor Group, on a ship called The Mayflower. Following a five week dispute over the contract with the adventurers, the passengers on the two ships set sail for America on August 5. Their voyage was soon interrupted when the smaller Speedwell was discovered to be leaking badly. They put into the port of Dartmouth, Devonshire, and repairs were made, but the condition reoccurred once they were under sail again. The two ships were forced to make port a second time, in neighboring Plymouth. There it was decided to leave the defective Speedwell behind, and continue with the Mayflower alone. The Speedwell's passengers and cargo were transferred to the larger ship, and on September 6, 1620, The Mayflower set sail across the North Atlantic and its famous 102 passengers, into history.

The Mayflower sighted land on November 9, 1620. It proved to be Cape Cod, which although the right latitude, was well east of their original destination at the mouth of the Hudson River. However, an encounter the following day with the shoals which lie off the outer Cape, as well as the lateness of the year, persuaded them to remain in the Cape area. The Mayflower came to anchor in what is today Provincetown harbor on November 11, after 66 days at sea. That day the male passengers signed the famous agreement we now know as the "Mayflower Compact".

The Mayflower remained in New England with the colonists throughout the terrible first winter. Although the ship was cold, damp and unheated, it did provide a defense against the rigorous New England winter until houses could be completed ashore. Nevertheless, exposure, malnutrition and illness led to the death of half the group, both passengers and crewmen

Thanksgiving Dinner
The tradition of the Pilgrims' first Thanksgiving is steeped in myth and legend. Few people realize that the Pilgrims did probably not celebrate Thanksgiving the next year, or any year thereafter, in the same manner as we do it now, though some of their descendants later made a "Forefather's Day" that usually occurred on December 21 or 22. Several Presidents, including George Washington, made one-time Thanksgiving holidays. In 1827, Mrs. Sarah Josepha Hale began lobbying several Presidents for the instatement of Thanksgiving as a national holiday, but her lobbying was unsuccessful until 1863 when Abraham Lincoln finally made it a national holiday with his 1863 Thanksgiving Proclamation.

Today, our Thanksgiving is the fourth Thursday of November. This was set by President Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1939 (approved by Congress in 1941), who changed it from Abraham Lincoln's designation as the last Thursday in November. The date of Thanksgiving was probably set by Lincoln to somewhat correlate with the anchoring of the Mayflower at Cape Cod, which occurred on November 21, 1620 (by our modern Gregorian calendar. It was November 11 to the Pilgrims, who used the Julian calendar).

But the Pilgrims' first "Thanksgiving" began at some unknown date between September 21 and November 9, most likely in very early October. Also, for the past 12 years, during their stay in Holland, the Pilgrims had grown accustomed to the "Leiden Liberation" celebration and "Thanksgiving" feast, held every year on October 3. The Leiden town has been celebrating this feast since 1574, after having been liberated from the Spanish by William of Orange after an 11 months siege. The Pilgrims had now combined that custom with some of the traditional English harvest celebration. This included games, recreations, three days of feasting and Indian guests. It would have been unthinkable for the Pilgrims to have these things as part of a religious Thanksgiving.

Then, a hundred years ago there was this inspirational image of the Pilgrims and the Native Americans sharing their communal meal in harmony. The country was seriously concerned over immigration and the problems surrounding the integration of the new citizens into American culture. The Thanksgiving image of dissimilar ethnic communities coexisting amid peace and plenty was an irresistible symbol. The Pilgrims became the exemplary immigrants whose Protestant virtues made them the preferred model for all later arrivals. Americanization programs, which were intended to socialize the new immigrants by instilling in them the values and beliefs of "real" Americans, made good use of the symbols and ideals of Thanksgiving and the Pilgrims. By 1920, when the Pilgrims' 300th anniversary celebration elevated them to the pinnacle of their fame, their role as Thanksgiving icons and the "spiritual ancestors" of all Americans became permanently fixed in the American psyche.

Some perhaps startling omissions from the authentic "Thanksgiving" menu:
- Ham. The Pilgrims most likely did not have pigs with them.
- Sweet Potatoes, Potatoes & Yams. These had not yet been introduced to New England.
- Corn on the cob. Indian corn was only good for making cornmeal, not eating on the cob.
- Popcorn. Indian corn could only be half-popped, but this did not taste good.
- Cranberry sauce. Cranberries were available, but sugar was not.
- Pumpkin Pie. They probably made a pumpkin pudding of sorts, sweetened by honey.

However, don't forget that our Thanksgiving dinner custom started in Leiden (Holland) over 400 years ago with their Thanksgiving dinner celebrations, remembering the hardship of Spanish prosecution and famine of the Dutch.

Willem van Osnabrugge,